| PES ID | FIFA ID | # | Player | Nationality | Height | Weight | Strong Foot | Team Name(s) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 101319 | - | 33 | RB Hayden White | England | 185cm | 68kg | Right | Indy Eleven |
| 102957 | - | 41 | CB James Musa | New Zealand | 185cm | 80kg | Left | Indy Eleven |
| 111435 | - | 32 | DMF Brem Soumaoro | Liberia | 188cm | 76kg | Right | Indy Eleven |
| 114161 | - | 5 | CMF James Murphy | United States | 180cm | 72kg | Right | Indy Eleven |
| 116247 | - | 9 | CF Romario Williams | Jamaica | 180cm | 77kg | Right | Indy Eleven |
| 123319 | - | 99 | RWF Maalique Foster | Jamaica | 170cm | 64kg | Right | Indy Eleven |
| 127157 | - | 23 | GK Reice Charles-Cook | Grenada | 185cm | 80kg | Right | Indy Eleven |
| 136825 | - | 18 | CF Elliot Collier | New Zealand | 193cm | 81kg | Right | Indy Eleven |
| 144334 | - | 16 | LB Aedan Stanley | United States | 178cm | 80kg | Left | Indy Eleven |
| 144349 | 260743 | 98 | GK Hunter Sulte | United States | 201cm | 82kg | Right | Indy Eleven |
| 144389 | 261362 | 19 | CF Edward Kizza | Uganda | 175cm | 77kg | Right | Indy Eleven |
| 148258 | - | 3 | CB Patrick Hogan | United States | 191cm | 90kg | Right | Indy Eleven |
| 148292 | - | 22 | CF Elvis Amoh | Ghana | 188cm | 75kg | Right | Indy Eleven |
| 148708 | - | 30 | CB Benjamin Ofeimu | United States | 191cm | 91kg | Right | Indy Eleven |
| 148860 | - | 8 | CMF Jack Blake | Scotland | 180cm | 67kg | Right | Indy Eleven |
| 148904 | - | 6 | CMF Cam Lindley | United States | 179cm | 75kg | Right | Indy Eleven |
| 148923 | 259300 | 14 | DMF Aodhan Quinn | United States | 183cm | 84kg | Left | Indy Eleven |
| 168776 | - | 17 | RB Logan Neidlinger | United States | 175cm | 71kg | Right | Indy Eleven |
| 168779 | - | 2 | CB Joshua O'Brien | Republic of Ireland | 193cm | 83kg | Right | Indy Eleven |
| 168934 | - | 55 | CB Maverick McCoy | United States | 188cm | 79kg | Right | Indy Eleven |
| 175578 | - | 27 | RB Bruno Rendón | Cuba | 188cm | 84kg | Right | Indy Eleven |
| 175579 | - | 21 | LMF Oliver Brynéus | Sweden | 185cm | 73kg | Left | Indy Eleven |
| 175810 | - | 44 | GK Ryan Hunsucker | United States | 191cm | 79kg | Right | Indy Eleven |